Companion Advisor: Taxes
& Estates |
Estate planning from the Muskoka chair
love their cottages and chalets. Many have been in the family for several
generations. Estate Plans must be set up to keep these much-loved properties
in the family for future generations.
In 1992 and in the couple of years following, there was a flurry of activity
and media coverage as cottage owners sought to crystallize capital gains
on the cottage and use their $100,000 capital gains exemption. Some owners
actually transferred cottages to children or into trusts. Others waited
and were able to take advantage of the simple filing of an election with
their 1994 income tax return. Still others did nothing. The ones who sheltered
part of the capital gain on their cottage still may have some estate planning
to do. Those who have procrastinated should get off the Muskoka chair
and do some estate planning as well.
The first question is when the plan should be effective ... now or at
death. For those who did not use their capital gains exemption to shelter
the gain in value, any transfer or sale during their lifetime will immediately
trigger the capital gain in the value of the cottage. This gain will need
to be declared and give rise to tax that is payable in the year in which
the transfer or sale takes place. The optimal plan may be to ensure that
the cottage owner has a valid Power of Attorney for the Management of
Property, perhaps stipulating that the cottage may be maintained during
the owner's incapacity for the use of other family members.
As well, the cottage owners should have a valid Will
providing a scheme or direction to the executors regarding the holding,
transfer or sale of the cottage. Thought should be given to placing life
insurance on the owners' lives to generate cash in the estate of the last
spouse to die. This tax-free cash could help pay the income tax owing
when the cottage passes to the next generation.
If there is not a large capital gain in the cottage value to be triggered
by a transfer by the owner, while alive, because the cottage has not appreciated
in value since purchased or the gain was sheltered, the owner has additional
options. These options are looked at to save or defer income tax and probate
fees. Several of the alternatives include:
1) Selling the cottage to your children, with or without a
low or no-interest mortgage;
2) Giving the cottage to your children, with or without a long-term
lease; Transferring the cottage into co-ownership with your children,
with or without survivorship rights;
3) Transferring the cottage, reserving an interest to use and
possess the cottage for your lifetime; or transferring the cottage
to a trust or corporation.
The owner can sell, give or transfer all or a part
ownership interest in the cottage. If the owner has no children or does
not wish the children to have the cottage, these same strategies can
be applied to other relatives or friends. When making these choices,
consider the following factors:
A) How much control the owner is willing to give up/how much
involvement the owner wishes to have;
B) Who should or will pay the cost of upkeep and maintenance
for the cottage, such as taxes, hydro and insurance;
C) Do the children want the cottage or do they live too far
away or have their own cottages already; the cost of making the arrangements
to sell, give or transfer the cottage, including legal and accounting
fees, income tax payable, land transfer tax, ongoing filing costs;
implications of family law legislation for both you and any adult
D) The possibility that a child's interest in the cottage
will be seized by creditors to pay outstanding debts of your child;
E) Changes required in your Will and other estate plans to
reflect the new arrangements.
The family cottage or chalet is a place for escape from the stresses
of everyday life. Use this article to stimulate discussion in your family
about a plan to keep the cottage in the family for the next generation.
Seek the help of an accountant and a lawyer to find the tax consequences
of various strategies and to implement a plan that works for you and
The information in this article is general and should not be relied
upon as a substitute for professional advice in specific situations.
©1999 - For more
information contact Suzanne Michaud, a lawyer practicing in association
with the Mississauga, Ontario law firm of Pallett Valo, Barristers and
Solicitors, working with clients in the area of family law.
* * *
||Use this link to load a printer-friendly
version of this document.
Have a question regarding this article? Use our feedback form to send us a note.
© , Fiscal Agents Money Management Newsletter
25 Lakeshore Road, Oakville, On L6K 1C6.